Why an Oregon Claim Needs an Oregon Trial Lawyer

Category:

Posted on:

Your crash happened on an Oregon road. Your surgery happened in an Oregon hospital. Your case deadlines come from Oregon statutes. If your case doesn’t settle, the people who decide what it’s worth will be twelve Oregonians sitting in a jury box. This is why hiring an Oregon trial lawyer matters.

Oregon cases deserve experienced Oregon trial lawyers: someone who knows this state’s law, has stood in front of this state’s juries, and has a record the insurance company on the other side already knows about. The team at Barton Trial Attorneys not only knows the difference between Multnomah Marion, Lane, and Lincoln juries, but can apply state-specific laws to benefit your case.

Here’s why that matters—along with cases our firm has tried right here in Oregon.

Speak to an Oregon Trial Lawyer

Questions to Ask Any Oregon Personal Injury Attorney

Before you hire anyone, ask:

  1. When did you last try a case to a jury in Oregon? Not settle, but try it (ie. went to trial).
  2. Is my type of case your main practice area? Car accidents, truck crashes, and medical malpractice each require different experts and different evidence.
  3. How many cases are you handling right now? A lawyer with hundreds of open files can’t give yours the attention it needs.
  4. Who will actually work on my case? You should meet the lawyer who will stand up in court.
  5. What will you do in the first 30 days? Evidence disappears quickly, especially in trucking and medical cases.

Oregon Law Is Its Own Rulebook

While many personal injury lawyers advertise in a dozen states at once, the law doesn’t work that way. Oregon’s rules are different from Washington’s, California’s, and Idaho’s, and some of the differences decide whether you recover anything at all. Here are a few that come up in almost every injury claim:

  • Two years to file. Most Oregon personal injury claims must be filed within two years of the injury under ORS 12.110. Medical malpractice claims have their own discovery rules and an outside limit. Claims against a public body can require written notice in as little as 180 days.
  • Modified comparative fault. Under ORS 31.600, you can still recover if you were partly at fault, as long as you were not more at fault than the people you’re suing. Your recovery is reduced by your share.
  • No cap on noneconomic damages in personal injury cases. In Busch v. McInnis Waste Systems (2020), a case in which a garbage truck struck a pedestrian in downtown Portland, the Oregon Supreme Court held that the state’s $500,000 cap could not be applied to an injured person’s claim. 
  • PIP coverage pays first. Every Oregon auto policy must carry personal injury protection. After an auto accident, your own PIP benefits usually pay early medical bills and some lost wages, regardless of who was at fault. How PIP gets repaid out of a later recovery is a trap for the unwary.
  • Juries don’t have to be unanimous. In Oregon civil cases, three-fourths of the jury can return a verdict. That changes how a trial lawyer picks a jury and builds a case.
  • There is limited pre-trial discovery, i.e. no disclosures of experts, their reports, or interrogatories (written questions to experts)

None of these rules is complicated on its own. Getting all of them right, in the right order, on the right timeline, is the job of your Oregon trial lawyer.

Speak to an Oregon Trial Attorney

Oregon Juries Vary By County

This point bears repeating: a jury in Portland is not a jury in Roseburg. A jury in Salem is not a jury in The Dalles. An Oregon personal injury attorney who has tried cases across this state learns how communities think about responsibility, money, and fairness, and builds the story for the people who will actually hear it.

Bill Barton learned that lesson early. In the 1980s he took on the Rajneeshees, the religious movement that took over the town of Antelope in Central Oregon. He represented a widowed mother whom the movement’s leader, Ma Anand Sheela, humiliated at a public school board meeting. The Rajneeshees parked members outside his home in Newport around the clock to intimidate him. He kept working. The jury found for his client. Read the full story here.

Decades later, in a Roseburg courtroom, our firm tried an obstetrical malpractice case against a popular and well-known local doctor. To show the jury what went wrong, we enlarged hours of fetal monitor strips onto foam boards that filled the courtroom. Jurors could watch the baby’s condition decline, hour by hour, minute by minute. Medical malpractice cases are won when ordinary people can see what the doctors should have seen. That takes a lawyer who knows how to show them.

Insurance Companies Play by Oregon Rules, Too

In 1989, Mark Goddard was killed by a drunk driver. His family sued the driver and won. Then the driver’s insurance company, Farmers, refused to pay. It denied coverage and denied any responsibility for its own insured.

Our firm didn’t let that stand. Our fight took 21 years and seven appeals. An Oregon jury returned a punitive damages verdict against Farmers, and ultimately the case helped shape Oregon’s insurance “bad faith” law. The principle is simple: an insurer cannot take your premiums and then, in bad faith, refuse to pay a claim it owes.

That history matters in ordinary cases, too. Insurance companies keep track of which personal injury lawyers will try a case and which will take the first offer. Adjusters set reserves accordingly. When the insurer knows your lawyer will go to trial, and will go to the appellate courts if needed, your claim is valued differently from day one.

Trial Experience Changes What a Case Is Worth

Most personal injury claims settle, but often for much less than they would receive at trial. The marginal value of going to trial depends largely on the law firm you have entrusted to represent you.

Consider a truck accident on Interstate 84 near Hood River. In August 2016, two Canadian tourists were riding bicycles legally on the shoulder when a semi-truck driven by an employee of Exel, Inc. struck them from behind. Eric Moutal’s leg was nearly severed.

The trucking company’s defense came down to one number. The driver was only going four miles per hour over the limit, its lawyers argued, and speeding alone is ordinary negligence under Oregon law.

Our trial team refused to let the jury judge one fact in isolation. We showed them the whole story. The driver had been drifting onto the shoulder for miles. He had driven past “Bicycles on Roadway” signs more than a thousand times and never noticed them. After the crash, he checked his truck for damage, called his supervisor instead of 911, and then followed witnesses around the scene trying to change their accounts until an Oregon State Trooper told him to stop.

The federal jury in Portland awarded $4 million in punitive damages: a million dollars for every mile per hour over the limit. The Ninth Circuit court upheld the verdict. (Moutal v. Exel, Inc., No. 3:17-cv-01444-HZ (D. Or. Mar. 29, 2021).) Read more about this verdict here.

Cases That Changed Oregon Law

Some cases do more than compensate one family; they can also change the rules for everyone who comes after. Barton Trial Attorneys has spent decades on cases involving powerful institutions that assumed no one would hold them accountable.

  • The first Boy Scouts case to go to trial in the United States. In Wilson v. Tobiassen, Bill Barton represented a Benton County boy abused by his Scoutmaster. It was the first lawsuit against the Boy Scouts of America to reach a jury verdict rather than settle.
  • A rule now written into Oregon’s jury instructions. In Doe v. Oregon Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists (2005), a Marion County jury held a church responsible because its officials knew of the danger and did nothing. The case is cited in Oregon’s Uniform Civil Jury Instructions on constructive knowledge. Bill calls the defense it defeated “ostrich management.”
  • The first lawsuit against the Vatican over clergy abuse. In Doe v. Holy See, a federal judge in Oregon ruled the case could proceed against the Vatican under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, a ruling the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part before the U.S. Supreme Court declined further review.
  • Oregon’s “as is” rule. In a case against a Eugene-area day care, Barton applied the principle that a wrongdoer takes a vulnerable victim as they find them: a defendant can’t escape responsibility because the person it hurt was already fragile.

These are Oregon cases with local plaintiffs: people who could be your neighbors, friends and community members. Standing up for Oregonians is what matters most to us.

Speak to an Oregon Personal Injury Attorney

Working With Barton Trial Attorneys

Years of experience matter less than what those years were spent doing. Here’s what ours look like.

Bill Barton earned his law degree from Willamette University College of Law in 1972 and has spent more than five decades as an Oregon trial lawyer. He has been certified by the Oregon Supreme Court as a judge pro tempore, served as president of the Oregon Trial Lawyers Association and the Oregon chapter of the American Board of Trial Advocates, and was inducted into the Trial Lawyer Hall of Fame in 2024. He has been named to Oregon Super Lawyers for more than fifteen years running.

Brent Barton earned his juris doctorate from Harvard Law School after graduate degrees from Stanford and Cambridge. He served in the Oregon House of Representatives, where he helped write the laws Oregon courts now apply. He has been named to Oregon Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers in America for plaintiffs’ medical malpractice and personal injury litigation.

Together, the firm brings more than seven decades of combined experience in Oregon courtrooms. We are a boutique personal injury law firm. We take a select few cases at a time and give each one two trial attorneys and a full staff. We are not mass-media advertisers, and we don’t run a volume practice.

Talk to an Oregon Trial Lawyer About Your Case

If you were hurt in Oregon, your case will be decided by Oregon law and, if it comes to it, an Oregon jury. You deserve trial lawyers who know both.

Barton Trial Attorneys handles serious personal injury claims across the state, including car accidents, truck accidents, medical malpractice, birth injuries, and wrongful death. See our results, meet our team, or contact us.

Call (541) 265-5377 for a free consultation. We take no fee unless we win.