Suing a Hospital vs. a Doctor in Oregon: Who Is Responsible?

Category:

Posted on:

When something goes wrong in a hospital, most families assume the hospital is responsible. In many cases, however, the doctor who treated you may not work for the hospital; they may work for a staffing company, or even a private medical group from out of state.

By Oregon law, legal responsibility depends on who made the mistake, who employed them, legal questions of agency, and whether the hospital itself did anything wrong. These details can affect who you can sue and how much compensation may be available. 

In this blog, the team at Barton Trial Attorneys explains the factors that may come into play when determining liability after a medical malpractice event.

Speak with an Oregon Medical Malpractice Attorney: Call (541) 265-5377

Two Ways an Oregon Hospital Can Be Liable for Medical Malpractice 

Oregon law recognizes two basic paths to holding a hospital accountable:

  • Responsibility for an employee or agent’s mistake. A hospital may be liable when someone working on its behalf causes an injury through negligence. Lawyers call this vicarious liability; or
  • Responsibility for the hospital’s own mistakes. A hospital may also be liable for unsafe staffing, poor training, or policies that put patients at risk. This is called direct liability.

Hospitals May Be Partially Responsible for a Doctor’s Mistake 

Some medical malpractice cases involve failures in the hospital itself. These problems can affect many patients, even when individual doctors and nurses are trying to provide good care. 

  • Too few nurses or medical staff. When too few people are caring for patients, warning signs or changes in a patient’s condition may go unnoticed. 
  • Unsafe or missing hospital policies. Hospitals need clear procedures for emergencies, patient transfers, and urgent test results. Missing or poorly followed policies can cause dangerous delays. 
  • Poor communication between medical teams. Important information may get lost when shifts change or test results are not passed along to the right doctor. 
  • Unsafe equipment or missing supplies. Broken monitors, missing medical supplies, or unavailable equipment can delay treatment and cause harm. 

A hospital’s staffing and safety decisions can affect the care patients receive. When a nurse has too many patients to monitor safely, the hospital’s staffing choices may become part of a medical malpractice claim. 

If you were injured by a doctor working in an Oregon hospital, you may have questions about who is legally responsible. Barton Trial Attorneys can investigate the relationship between the doctor and hospital and help determine whether you have a claim, and against whom. Contact Barton Trial Attorneys at (541) 265-5377 for a free consultation. 

When Is a Hospital Responsible for a Doctor’s or Nurse’s Mistake? 

Hospitals are generally responsible when employees or agents cause harm through negligence while doing their jobs. This can include mistakes made by nurses, doctors, or other medical staff. 

If someone fails to report a patient’s worsening condition, gives the wrong medication, or misses signs of distress on a fetal monitor, the hospital may be responsible for the harm that follows. If an employed doctor causes harm through negligence while working, the hospital will probably also be liable. Several basic questions may further establish if a hospital is responsible for a doctor’s medical malpractice:

  • Did the patient choose the doctor, or did the hospital assign one? 
  • Did hospital signs, forms, or staff make the doctor appear to be an employee?
  • Did the hospital explain to the patient that the doctor worked independently? 

These questions are especially important in emergency rooms, where patients often have no choice about who treats them, and may not even have the capacity to knowingly consent. 

When the Doctor Is an Independent Contractor

Many doctors who treat patients in hospitals work for private medical groups or staffing companies. This is common among emergency room doctors, anesthesiologists, radiologists, and some surgeons. They may have permission to treat patients at the hospital without being hospital employees. 

If an independent doctor makes a mistake, the hospital may argue that the doctor or their employer is responsible. However, an independent contractor agreement does not protect a hospital from liability if the doctor was an actual, or apparent agent. 

When a Hospital Appears to Employ the Doctor

Sometimes a hospital can be held responsible for a doctor’s mistake even if the doctor is not an employee. This may happen when the hospital leads patients to believe the doctor works for it, and patients reasonably rely on that impression. Oregon law calls this apparent agency. 

In Towner v. Bernardo/Silverton Health, the Oregon Court of Appeals ruled that a jury could find a surgeon was acting as an apparent agent of the hospital, even though he was not its employee. Our own Brent Barton successfully argued the appeal on behalf of the injured patient. The resulting decision shows why the relationship between a doctor and hospital deserves careful review. 

Can a Hospital Be Liable for Hiring or Keeping an Unsafe Doctor? 

Hospitals must take reasonable care when deciding which doctors can treat patients in their facilities. If a hospital ignores warning signs about a doctor’s qualifications or performance, it may be responsible for injuries that result. This is known as negligent credentialing or supervision.

In Towner v. Bernardo/Silverton Health, the Oregon Court of Appeals allowed claims involving a hospital’s decision to grant and maintain a surgeon’s privileges to move forward. Although some internal hospital review records are confidential under Oregon law, other evidence may help show what the hospital knew or should have known.

Work with an Oregon Medical Malpractice Lawyer

Filing Against an Oregon Public Hospital? Act Quickly To Protect Your Claim

Most personal injury claims against public hospitals require notice within 180 days. Wrongful death claims generally have a one-year notice deadline. Public hospitals may also be subject to statutory limits on compensation. It is critical to identify whether a hospital is publicly or privately operated before filing a claim, as missing a required deadline can prevent a lawsuit, even when a patient has suffered serious harm. 

Early investigation can help determine who employed each medical provider, who supervised their work, and who allowed them to practice at the hospital. If you believe medical negligence caused a serious injury, speak with an Oregon medical malpractice attorney as soon as possible to understand which deadlines apply.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue both the hospital and the doctor?

Yes, you may be able to sue both if the doctor was negligent and the hospital was legally responsible for the doctor’s actions or made mistakes of its own. An attorney can review the facts to determine who may be liable. 

How do I know if my doctor was a hospital employee?

Often you cannot tell from the outside. Check your consent forms, which sometimes include a notice that physicians are independent. Separate bills from a physician group are another clue. A lawyer can confirm the relationship through contracts and records.

Does an independent contractor disclaimer end my claim? 

Not necessarily. A disclaimer is one factor courts may consider. The hospital’s actions, the information given to the patient, and the patient’s reasonable understanding of the doctor’s role may also matter. 

What about emergency room doctors?

ER doctors are frequently independent contractors employed by physician staffing companies. That can make apparent agency especially important, because ER patients do not choose their doctor.